# Pigmented eyeliner

Source: HiveTried, https://hivetried.com/beauty/eyeliner/pigmented/
Category: Beauty > Eyeliner. Updated 2026-10-17. Based on 255 counted first-hand reports from shopper reviews from two large US beauty stores, Aug 2019 to Oct 2026.

**Question:** Which eyeliner gives rich, opaque color?

**Short answer:** Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eyeliner Pencil has the best record, with 27 of 28 shoppers saying their liner gave deep, opaque color, and e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner is close enough at 15 of 15 that the two could swap places. Urban Decay 24/7 Liquid Stick Eyeliner follows at 28 of 30, and the records fall from there to 23 of 48 for Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eye Liner, the weakest record here. Each record counts just shoppers who said how strong the color was.

**What stands out:** Drying out fast comes up for the three liquid liners, in 24% of reviews for Benefit Roller Liner, 23% for KVD Beauty Tattoo Liner and 30% for Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eye Liner, and in no review of the pencils or the Liquid Stick.

## Ranking (buyers who said whether it worked)

| Rank | Product | Rich color | Share | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eyeliner Pencil | 27 of 28 | 96% | yes |
| 2 | e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner | 15 of 15 | 100% | yes |
| 3 | Urban Decay 24/7 Liquid Stick Eyeliner | 28 of 30 | 93% | yes |
| 4 | Benefit Roller Liner | 36 of 44 | 82% | yes |
| 5 | Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eyeliner Pencil | 19 of 28 | 68% | yes |
| 6 | KVD Beauty Tattoo Liner | 14 of 21 | 67% | yes |
| 7 | Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eye Liner | 23 of 48 | 48% | no |

Ranked by the lower bound of a 90% Wilson confidence interval, so a product needs a high share and enough reports to rank high. An Amazon link is shown only when at least 60% say it works.

## Product notes

### 1. Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eyeliner Pencil

Shoppers say this pencil stays on the waterline in 39% of its 33 reviews and glides on in 67%, with 39% saying it doesn't smudge.

- Praised for: Glides on (67%), Lasts all day (64%), Stays on the waterline (39%)
- Complaints: Fades during the day (9%), Smudges (6%)
- Reports counted: 33

### 2. e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner

Good value comes up in 32% of its 19 reviews and a smooth glide in 53%, though 16% say this kohl pencil smudges.

- Praised for: Glides on (53%), Lasts all day (37%), Good value (32%)
- Complaints: Smudges (16%), Fades during the day (16%)
- Reports counted: 19

### 3. Urban Decay 24/7 Liquid Stick Eyeliner

Of its 35 reviews, 57% mention a smooth glide and 23% a precise line. Smudging comes up in 17%, and 9% find this retractable stick hard to control.

- Praised for: Glides on (57%), Lasts all day (37%), Doesn't smudge (29%)
- Complaints: Smudges (17%), Too expensive (9%), Hard to control (9%)
- Reports counted: 35

### 4. Benefit Roller Liner

Easy application draws praise in 24% of its 58 reviews and a precise line in 22%, while 17% say this roller liner smudges and 10% find it hard to control.

- Praised for: Easy to apply (24%), Lasts all day (24%), Easy, precise line (22%)
- Complaints: Dries out fast (24%), Smudges (17%), Hard to control (10%)
- Reports counted: 58

### 5. Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eyeliner Pencil

In 27% of its 30 reviews, shoppers say this pencil glides on, and 17% say it stays on the waterline.

- Praised for: Glides on (27%), Lasts all day (27%), Stays on the waterline (17%)
- Complaints: Fades during the day (7%)
- Reports counted: 30

### 6. KVD Beauty Tattoo Liner

Out of 26 reviews, easy application comes up in 23% and a precise line in 19%, though 12% say it skips or tugs.

- Praised for: Lasts all day (35%), Doesn't smudge (23%), Easy to apply (23%)
- Complaints: Dries out fast (23%), Skips or tugs (12%), Fades during the day (8%)
- Reports counted: 26

### 7. Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eye Liner

More shoppers stated a result for this liquid liner than for any other liner here. A precise line comes up in 19% of its 54 reviews and easy application in 15%, though 9% say the color fades during the day.

- Praised for: Lasts all day (31%), Easy, precise line (19%), Doesn't smudge (15%)
- Complaints: Dries out fast (30%), Fades during the day (9%), Smudges (6%)
- Reports counted: 54

## Questions

**Which eyeliners do shoppers say give deep, opaque color?**

In order, the records are Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eyeliner Pencil (27 of 28), e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner (15 of 15), Urban Decay 24/7 Liquid Stick Eyeliner (28 of 30), Benefit Roller Liner (36 of 44), Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eyeliner Pencil (19 of 28), KVD Beauty Tattoo Liner (14 of 21) and Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eye Liner (23 of 48). The ranking weighs the size of a group as well as its share, which is why Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eyeliner Pencil, with a lower share on a larger group, sits just above e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner.

**How many shoppers are behind each record?**

The groups run from 15 shoppers for e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner to 48 for Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eye Liner, so the smaller records deserve a careful read. Not every review says how strong the color was, which is why a record rests on fewer shoppers than the reviews we read.

**Which of these eyeliners are sold on Amazon?**

Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eyeliner Pencil, e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner, Urban Decay 24/7 Liquid Stick Eyeliner, Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eyeliner Pencil and KVD Beauty Tattoo Liner are sold on Amazon by the brand or Amazon itself. Benefit Roller Liner is sold there through third-party sellers. Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eye Liner has no buy link here, because too few shoppers reported a good result for us to recommend it.

**Do these records promise an eyeliner will give strong color?**

No, these records come from shoppers who said how strong the color was. People mostly bring that up when they like the result, so the numbers compare the liners with each other rather than promise a result. The counts are what shoppers said after using each liner, not a lab test, so follow the label directions.

## Method

HiveTried counts first-hand reports only, drops reviews written for free products, shows brand-site reviews without counting them, and never accepts payment for placement. Full method: https://hivetried.com/how-we-count/
