Pigmented eyeliner

Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eyeliner Pencil has the best record, with 27 of 28 shoppers saying their liner gave deep, opaque color, and e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner is close enough at 15 of 15 that the two could swap places. Urban Decay 24/7 Liquid Stick Eyeliner follows at 28 of 30, and the records fall from there to 23 of 48 for Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eye Liner, the weakest record here. Each record counts just shoppers who said how strong the color was.

Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eyeliner Pencil
Top pick Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eyeliner Pencil 27 of 28 say it gave deep, opaque color
See price & reviews on Amazon Paid link. The ranking never depends on it.
  • 255 store reviews counted
  • Shoppers at two beauty stores
  • Aug 2019 to Oct 2026

Updated . How we count

Was the color strong? What shoppers said
  1. e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner 15 said either way
  2. Benefit Roller Liner 44 said either way
  3. KVD Beauty Tattoo Liner 21 said either way

Share of reviewers who stated an outcome for color strength. Ranked by the lower bound of a 90% confidence interval, so a product needs both a good share and enough reports to rank high.

Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eyeliner Pencil Best record Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eyeliner Pencil 27 of 28 say it gave deep, opaque color See price & reviews on Amazon
What stands out

Drying out fast comes up for the three liquid liners, in 24% of reviews for Benefit Roller Liner, 23% for KVD Beauty Tattoo Liner and 30% for Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eye Liner, and in no review of the pencils or the Liquid Stick.

The ranking, product by product

Praise and complaints are the points reviewers repeat most, shown as a share of each product's counted store reviews.

1 Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eyeliner Pencil

Urban Decay

24/7 Waterline Eyeliner Pencil

Best for the waterline

27/28 say it gave deep, opaque color

Shoppers say this pencil stays on the waterline in 39% of its 33 reviews and glides on in 67%, with 39% saying it doesn't smudge.

What buyers praise

  • Glides on 67%
  • Lasts all day 64%
  • Stays on the waterline 39%
  • Doesn't smudge 39%
  • Easy to apply 21%

What buyers complain about

  • Fades during the day 9%
  • Smudges 6%
Where buyers said it
  • Store A 25 of 25
  • Store B 2 of 3
2 e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner

e.l.f.

Smoky Kohl Eyeliner

Best for value

15/15 say it gave deep, opaque color

Good value comes up in 32% of its 19 reviews and a smooth glide in 53%, though 16% say this kohl pencil smudges.

What buyers praise

  • Glides on 53%
  • Lasts all day 37%
  • Good value 32%
  • Doesn't smudge 21%
  • Easy to apply 21%

What buyers complain about

  • Smudges 16%
  • Fades during the day 16%
Where buyers said it
  • Store A 15 of 15
  • Brand site 3 of 3 shown, not counted
3 Urban Decay 24/7 Liquid Stick Eyeliner

Urban Decay

24/7 Liquid Stick Eyeliner

28/30 say it gave deep, opaque color

Of its 35 reviews, 57% mention a smooth glide and 23% a precise line. Smudging comes up in 17%, and 9% find this retractable stick hard to control.

What buyers praise

  • Glides on 57%
  • Lasts all day 37%
  • Doesn't smudge 29%
  • Easy to apply 29%
  • Easy, precise line 23%

What buyers complain about

  • Smudges 17%
  • Too expensive 9%
  • Hard to control 9%
  • Fades during the day 6%
Where buyers said it
  • Store A 23 of 25
  • Store B 5 of 5
4 Benefit Roller Liner

Benefit

Roller Liner

36/44 say it gave deep, opaque color

Easy application draws praise in 24% of its 58 reviews and a precise line in 22%, while 17% say this roller liner smudges and 10% find it hard to control.

What buyers praise

  • Easy to apply 24%
  • Lasts all day 24%
  • Easy, precise line 22%
  • Glides on 21%
  • Doesn't smudge 16%

What buyers complain about

  • Dries out fast 24%
  • Smudges 17%
  • Hard to control 10%
  • Too expensive 7%
  • Hard to wing 5%
Where buyers said it
  • Store A 17 of 21
  • Store B 19 of 23
By skin type (from reviewer profiles)
  • Combination12 of 15
  • Oily3 of 4
By skin tone (from reviewer profiles)
  • Fair to light13 of 16
  • Light-medium to medium4 of 5
See price & reviews on Amazon

Share of 58 store reviews that mention each point. A full bar is 50%.

5 Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eyeliner Pencil

Urban Decay

24/7 Glide-On Eyeliner Pencil

19/28 say it gave deep, opaque color

In 27% of its 30 reviews, shoppers say this pencil glides on, and 17% say it stays on the waterline.

What buyers praise

  • Glides on 27%
  • Lasts all day 27%
  • Stays on the waterline 17%
  • Doesn't smudge 17%
  • Easy to apply 10%

What buyers complain about

  • Fades during the day 7%
Where buyers said it
  • Store B 19 of 28
By skin type (from reviewer profiles)
  • Combination5 of 11
  • Dry2 of 4
  • Normal4 of 4
By skin tone (from reviewer profiles)
  • Fair to light5 of 9
  • Light-medium to medium5 of 6
By age (reviewers who gave one)
  • Under 403 of 4
  • 40 and over2 of 4
6 KVD Beauty Tattoo Liner

KVD Beauty

Tattoo Liner

14/21 say it gave deep, opaque color

Out of 26 reviews, easy application comes up in 23% and a precise line in 19%, though 12% say it skips or tugs.

What buyers praise

  • Lasts all day 35%
  • Doesn't smudge 23%
  • Easy to apply 23%
  • Easy, precise line 19%
  • Glides on 15%

What buyers complain about

  • Dries out fast 23%
  • Skips or tugs 12%
  • Fades during the day 8%
Where buyers said it
  • Store B 14 of 21
By skin type (from reviewer profiles)
  • Combination7 of 11
  • Dry4 of 6
By skin tone (from reviewer profiles)
  • Fair to light7 of 13
  • Light-medium to medium6 of 7
7

Stila

Stay All Day Liquid Eye Liner

23/48 say it gave deep, opaque color

More shoppers stated a result for this liquid liner than for any other liner here. A precise line comes up in 19% of its 54 reviews and easy application in 15%, though 9% say the color fades during the day.

What buyers praise

  • Lasts all day 31%
  • Easy, precise line 19%
  • Doesn't smudge 15%
  • Easy to apply 15%
  • Glides on 9%

What buyers complain about

  • Dries out fast 30%
  • Fades during the day 9%
  • Smudges 6%
  • Too expensive 4%
  • Hard to control 4%
Where buyers said it
  • Store A 7 of 20
  • Store B 16 of 28
By skin type (from reviewer profiles)
  • Combination8 of 13
  • Oily1 of 5
  • Normal3 of 4
By skin tone (from reviewer profiles)
  • Fair to light10 of 13
  • Light-medium to medium3 of 7
By age (reviewers who gave one)
  • Under 406 of 8
  • 40 and over1 of 3

Share of 54 store reviews that mention each point. A full bar is 50%.

Where these numbers come from

The 7 products ranked here carry 116,687 reviews at two large US beauty stores (Store A and Store B on the cards). We searched them for color strength and read the newest matching reviews, up to 40 per product and store, posted between Aug 2019 and Oct 2026.

A review counts only when the reviewer used the product themselves. We drop reviews written in exchange for a free product or a sweepstakes entry (14 on this page), and products that are no longer sold.

Store A also shows reviews first posted on brands' own websites. They run much more positive than store reviews of the same products (across 19 products with both, 76% of brand-site reviewers said the product solved the problem, against 55% of Store A shoppers), so we show them on product cards but never count them.

Because we searched for the problem, people who had it are overrepresented. Compare products with each other rather than reading a share as your own odds.

Skin type, skin tone and age splits use what reviewers chose on Store B's review form (and age on Store A's when given). We only show a split when enough reviewers fall on each side.

Amazon buttons appear only on products that most reviewers here say fix the problem (at least 60%, with enough reviews to trust it). Everything else gets no buy link.

An AI model labels each review against a fixed list of points, and we spot-check the labels before publishing. We publish counts, never the reviews themselves.

Read the full method

Product pages we read

  1. Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eyeliner Pencil Store A and Store B (33 reviews counted)
  2. e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner Store A (19 reviews counted)
  3. Urban Decay 24/7 Liquid Stick Eyeliner Store A and Store B (35 reviews counted)
  4. Benefit Roller Liner Store A and Store B (58 reviews counted)
  5. Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eyeliner Pencil Store A and Store B (30 reviews counted)
  6. KVD Beauty Tattoo Liner Store B (26 reviews counted)
  7. Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eye Liner Store A and Store B (54 reviews counted)

Questions buyers ask

Which eyeliners do shoppers say give deep, opaque color?

In order, the records are Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eyeliner Pencil (27 of 28), e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner (15 of 15), Urban Decay 24/7 Liquid Stick Eyeliner (28 of 30), Benefit Roller Liner (36 of 44), Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eyeliner Pencil (19 of 28), KVD Beauty Tattoo Liner (14 of 21) and Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eye Liner (23 of 48). The ranking weighs the size of a group as well as its share, which is why Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eyeliner Pencil, with a lower share on a larger group, sits just above e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner.

How many shoppers are behind each record?

The groups run from 15 shoppers for e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner to 48 for Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eye Liner, so the smaller records deserve a careful read. Not every review says how strong the color was, which is why a record rests on fewer shoppers than the reviews we read.

Which of these eyeliners are sold on Amazon?

Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eyeliner Pencil, e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner, Urban Decay 24/7 Liquid Stick Eyeliner, Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eyeliner Pencil and KVD Beauty Tattoo Liner are sold on Amazon by the brand or Amazon itself. Benefit Roller Liner is sold there through third-party sellers. Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eye Liner has no buy link here, because too few shoppers reported a good result for us to recommend it.

Do these records promise an eyeliner will give strong color?

No, these records come from shoppers who said how strong the color was. People mostly bring that up when they like the result, so the numbers compare the liners with each other rather than promise a result. The counts are what shoppers said after using each liner, not a lab test, so follow the label directions.

HiveTried earns a commission when you buy through the Amazon buttons on this page. It never changes the ranking: the order comes from buyer reports only, and a product gets an Amazon button only when buyers here say it works.