Pigmented lip gloss

YSL Candy Glaze Lip Gloss Stick has the best record at 16 of 16, and NYX Butter Gloss follows at 18 of 19, though both rest on small groups. Buxom Full-On Plumping Lip Polish has the weakest record here, with shoppers split at 14 of 25, while the other four all score 89% or better. Each record counts just shoppers who said whether the color showed up well.

NYX Butter Gloss
Best pick on Amazon NYX Butter Gloss 18 of 19 say it gave real color
See price & reviews on Amazon Paid link. The ranking never depends on it.
  • 188 store reviews counted
  • Shoppers at two beauty stores
  • Oct 2016 to Oct 2026

Updated . How we count

Did it give real color? What shoppers said
  1. NYX Butter Gloss 19 said either way

Share of reviewers who stated an outcome for color payoff. Ranked by the lower bound of a 90% confidence interval, so a product needs both a good share and enough reports to rank high.

Best record YSL Candy Glaze Lip Gloss Stick 16 of 16 say it gave real color
NYX Butter Gloss Best pick on Amazon NYX Butter Gloss 18 of 19 say it gave real color See price & reviews on Amazon

The ranking, product by product

Praise and complaints are the points reviewers repeat most, shown as a share of each product's counted store reviews.

1

YSL

Candy Glaze Lip Gloss Stick

16/16 say it gave real color

Shoppers mention comfort in 43% of its 23 reviews and shine in 39%, and price is the main complaint, at 17%.

What buyers praise

  • Comfortable, hydrating 43%
  • Glossy shine 39%
  • Lasts a while 30%
  • Flattering color 30%
  • Hydrating 17%

What buyers complain about

  • Too expensive 17%
  • Wears off fast 13%
  • Thick or goopy 9%
  • Leaks or bad applicator 9%
Where buyers said it
  • Store B 16 of 16
By skin type (from reviewer profiles)
  • Combination6 of 6
  • Normal5 of 5
  • Dry3 of 3
By skin tone (from reviewer profiles)
  • Fair to light11 of 11
  • Light-medium to medium4 of 4

Share of 23 store reviews that mention each point. A full bar is 50%.

2 NYX Butter Gloss

NYX

Butter Gloss

Best for value

18/19 say it gave real color

Good value comes up in 20% of its 30 reviews and a non-sticky feel in 30%, while 10% complain about the applicator.

What buyers praise

  • Not sticky 30%
  • Flattering color 23%
  • Good value 20%
  • Lasts a while 17%
  • Comfortable, hydrating 17%

What buyers complain about

  • Leaks or bad applicator 10%
  • Wears off fast 7%
Where buyers said it
  • Store A 18 of 19
3

Fenty Beauty

Gloss Bomb Lip Luminizer

34/38 say it gave real color

More shoppers said whether the color showed up for this gloss than for any other here. Of its 50 reviews, 30% say it lasts a while and 26% call it comfortable, while 8% say it wears off fast.

What buyers praise

  • Flattering color 36%
  • Lasts a while 30%
  • Comfortable, hydrating 26%
  • Glossy shine 20%
  • Not sticky 20%

What buyers complain about

  • Wears off fast 8%
  • Too expensive 6%
  • Bad scent or taste 4%
  • Leaks or bad applicator 4%
Where buyers said it
  • Store A 14 of 16
  • Store B 20 of 22
By skin type (from reviewer profiles)
  • Combination6 of 6
  • Normal4 of 5
  • Dry4 of 4
By skin tone (from reviewer profiles)
  • Fair to light10 of 10
  • Light-medium to medium4 of 4

Share of 50 store reviews that mention each point. A full bar is 50%.

4 Huda Beauty Faux Filler Lip Gloss

Huda Beauty

Faux Filler Lip Gloss

Best for a non-sticky feel

23/25 say it gave real color

Shoppers call it non-sticky in 37% of its 30 reviews and comfortable in 27%, and its 2 misses found the color too sheer.

What buyers praise

  • Not sticky 37%
  • Flattering color 33%
  • Comfortable, hydrating 27%
  • Glossy shine 23%
  • Pleasant scent or taste 17%

What buyers complain about

No repeated complaints yet.

Where buyers said it
  • Store B 23 of 25
By skin type (from reviewer profiles)
  • Combination6 of 7
  • Dry6 of 6
  • Oily3 of 3
By skin tone (from reviewer profiles)
  • Fair to light8 of 8
  • Light-medium to medium6 of 6
  • Medium-tan to tan2 of 3
See price & reviews on Amazon

Share of 30 store reviews that mention each point. A full bar is 50%.

5

Buxom

Full-On Plumping Lip Polish

14/25 say it gave real color

Its 11 misses said the color went on sheer, closer to a tint than full color. Shine draws praise in 22% of its 55 reviews, and 7% call it too expensive.

What buyers praise

  • Lasts a while 35%
  • Comfortable, hydrating 24%
  • Glossy shine 22%
  • Flattering color 16%
  • Hydrating 13%

What buyers complain about

  • Too expensive 7%
  • Sticky 5%
  • Wears off fast 5%
  • Dries lips 4%
  • Thick or goopy 4%
Where buyers said it
  • Store A 8 of 13
  • Store B 6 of 12
By skin type (from reviewer profiles)
  • Combination3 of 7
  • Dry2 of 3

Share of 55 store reviews that mention each point. A full bar is 50%.

Where these numbers come from

The 5 products ranked here carry 47,734 reviews at two large US beauty stores (Store A and Store B on the cards). We searched them for color payoff and read the newest matching reviews, up to 40 per product and store, posted between Oct 2016 and Oct 2026.

A review counts only when the reviewer used the product themselves. We drop reviews written in exchange for a free product or a sweepstakes entry (0 on this page), and products that are no longer sold.

Store A also shows reviews first posted on brands' own websites. They run much more positive than store reviews of the same products (across 19 products with both, 76% of brand-site reviewers said the product solved the problem, against 55% of Store A shoppers), so we show them on product cards but never count them.

Because we searched for the problem, people who had it are overrepresented. Compare products with each other rather than reading a share as your own odds.

Skin type, skin tone and age splits use what reviewers chose on Store B's review form (and age on Store A's when given). We only show a split when enough reviewers fall on each side.

Amazon buttons appear only on products that most reviewers here say fix the problem (at least 60%, with enough reviews to trust it). Everything else gets no buy link.

An AI model labels each review against a fixed list of points, and we spot-check the labels before publishing. We publish counts, never the reviews themselves.

Read the full method

Product pages we read

  1. YSL Candy Glaze Lip Gloss Stick Store B (23 reviews counted)
  2. NYX Butter Gloss Store A (30 reviews counted)
  3. Fenty Beauty Gloss Bomb Lip Luminizer Store A and Store B (50 reviews counted)
  4. Huda Beauty Faux Filler Lip Gloss Store B (30 reviews counted)
  5. Buxom Full-On Plumping Lip Polish Store A and Store B (55 reviews counted)

Questions buyers ask

Which lip gloss gives real color and not just shine?

YSL Candy Glaze Lip Gloss Stick has the best record (16 of 16), followed by NYX Butter Gloss (18 of 19), Fenty Beauty Gloss Bomb Lip Luminizer (34 of 38), Huda Beauty Faux Filler Lip Gloss (23 of 25) and Buxom Full-On Plumping Lip Polish (14 of 25). Fenty Beauty Gloss Bomb Lip Luminizer and Huda Beauty Faux Filler Lip Gloss are close, so either order between them is fair.

Do these records promise a lip gloss will show real color?

They don't. These records come from shoppers who chose to mention color payoff, usually to praise it, so the numbers compare the glosses with each other rather than promise a result. The counts are what shoppers said after using each gloss, not a lab test, so follow the label directions.

Are these lip glosses sticky?

Few shoppers say so. A non-sticky feel comes up for all five, from 13% of the 55 reviews for Buxom Full-On Plumping Lip Polish to 37% of the 30 for Huda Beauty Faux Filler Lip Gloss, and just Buxom Full-On Plumping Lip Polish draws a repeated sticky complaint, at 5%.

Which of these lip glosses are sold on Amazon?

NYX Butter Gloss is the best pick sold on Amazon by the brand or Amazon itself. Huda Beauty Faux Filler Lip Gloss is sold there through third-party sellers. We found no official Amazon listing for YSL Candy Glaze Lip Gloss Stick, the leader, or for Fenty Beauty Gloss Bomb Lip Luminizer, so neither has a buy link here. Buxom Full-On Plumping Lip Polish has no buy link here, because too few shoppers reported a good result for us to recommend it.

HiveTried earns a commission when you buy through the Amazon buttons on this page. It never changes the ranking: the order comes from buyer reports only, and a product gets an Amazon button only when buyers here say it works.