Full coverage concealer

2

e.l.f.

Hydrating Camo Concealer

Best for good value

31/34 say it covered dark circles, spots or blemishes the way they wanted

Reviewers like what they get for the price: 22% call it good value and 20% say it lasts all day. 31 of 34 said it covered what they wanted, and the brand's own site agrees at 10 of 10, which we show but don't count. Shade is the catch. 12% say it was hard to find a shade, though 15% matched easily, and 10% say it creases.

3

Too Faced

Born This Way Super Coverage Concealer

Best for lasts all day

14/15 say it covered dark circles, spots or blemishes the way they wanted

The share is high at 14 of 15, but a smaller group weighed in, so the record is thinner than the others. 26% say it lasts all day. 11% say it was hard to find a shade and 11% say it oxidized or turned grey.

4

COVERGIRL

TruBlend Undercover Concealer

19/21 say it covered dark circles, spots or blemishes the way they wanted

Coverage is the draw: 19 of 21 reviewers said it covered what they wanted, and 13% call it good value. The complaints come after application. 13% say it settles into fine lines, 13% say it creases and 9% had trouble finding a shade.

5

L'Oréal Paris

Infallible Full Wear Concealer

32/37 say it covered dark circles, spots or blemishes the way they wanted

More reviewers weighed in on this one than on any other concealer here (37), and 32 of 37 said it covered what they wanted. 22% say it lasts all day. Complaints split three ways, with 12% saying the coverage isn't enough, 12% saying it creases and 10% saying it looks cakey.

6

Revlon

PhotoReady Concealer

Best for blends easily

19/23 say it covered dark circles, spots or blemishes the way they wanted

Reviewers call it easy to blend, at 22%, and 17% say it brightens. 13% say it doesn't crease. 19 of 23 said it covered what they wanted, and the main complaint is coverage that felt too sheer, at 17%.

7

Maybelline

Instant Age Rewind Eraser

Best for easy shade match

24/31 say it covered dark circles, spots or blemishes the way they wanted

Shade match gets the praise, with 26% saying it was easy to match and 16% saying it blends easily. Coverage is where it slips. 23% of its reviews say it isn't enough, which gives it the weakest record here at 24 of 31. Its listing sells it as medium to full coverage.