Concealer for dark spots

More shoppers stated an outcome for this one than for any other concealer here, and 38 of 41 said it covered their dark spots. Looking at all 46 of its reviews, 35% say it covers blemishes and 15% call the finish natural. Complaints are scattered, including 7% who say it creases and 7% who say it doesn't cover enough.

3

Tarte

Shape Tape Concealer

12/12 say it covered their dark spots

12 of 12 shoppers said it covered their dark spots, which is the highest share here, though it rests on a small group. Looking at all 14 of its reviews, 21% say it is fine on mature skin and 21% say it covers blemishes.

Blemish coverage draws the praise: across all 30 of its reviews, 60% say it covers blemishes. 26 of 28 shoppers said it covered their dark spots. The catches are finding a shade (10%) and a dry look or fine lines (10%).

5

bareMinerals

Loose Powder Concealer

22/24 say it covered their dark spots

Shoppers who stated an outcome mostly said this loose powder concealer covered their dark spots, at 22 of 24. Across all 30 of its reviews, 30% say it covers blemishes and 10% say it lasts all day, though 7% say a matching shade was hard to find.

It has the weakest record here at 25 of 28, a tie with Benefit Boi-ing Industrial Strength Concealer. Across all 30 of its reviews, 33% say it lasts all day, though 10% say it is hard to blend, 10% say it oxidizes or turns gray and 10% say it doesn't cover enough.

7

Benefit

Boi-ing Industrial Strength Concealer

25/28 say it covered their dark spots

Blending and creasing both come up. Across all 30 of its reviews, 20% say it blends easily and 13% say it creases, while 60% say it covers blemishes. Its record is 25 of 28, the same as MAKE UP FOR EVER Full Cover Concealer.